The four categories
Work out which question you have before comparing products.
| Category | Question it answers | Evidence type | Names the claimant? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Record check | Has anyone asked Google to delist URLs on this domain? | Primary source: the published record | Yes |
| Index-status scanner | Is this URL in Google right now? | Inference from absence | No |
| Protection badge | Am I registered with this vendor? | None: it's a registration | No |
| Counter-notice service | Will someone file the paperwork for me? | Not a check: a done-for-you service | Usually, as part of the work |
Record checks
Searches Google's published copyright-removal data by domain: the requests, reporting organisation, copyright owner, URLs listed and Google's action.
Limits
- Search only, not YouTube or other products.
- Excludes fax and letter notices, and notices sent to your host.
- Publication lags submission: a very recent request may not show yet.
- Shows what was claimed and decided, not whether the claim was legally correct.
Strengths
- Primary-source evidence, not inference.
- The only category that shows who filed, which you need to resolve anything.
- Works on domains you don't own, with no verification.
- Shows history and patterns, not a single moment.
Index-status scanners
Test whether each URL is still in Google, and present a missing one as a probable removal.
Limits
- Absence is ambiguous:
noindex, a robots block, a canonical elsewhere, never-indexed pages, crawl errors and quality drops look identical to a delisting, and the scanner can't tell them apart. - Can't tell you who filed: that isn't in the signal.
Strengths
- Show current reality, so can catch a very recent removal before the data does.
- Work per URL, which suits checking one page.
Treat "missing" as a symptom to investigate, not a diagnosis.
Protection badges
A logo plus a verification token (meta tag or DNS record) proving you control the domain; some bundle takedown help. A badge checks nothing, carries no weight with Google and doesn't create copyright, which exists on creation. A dmca-site-verification tag doesn't mean anything is being monitored.
Done-for-you counter-notice services
Not checking tools: businesses that file counter-notifications for you, often priced per URL or domain, sometimes on success fees. Many offer a free scanner as a lead magnet, built to find a problem they then sell a fix for.
For a genuinely wrongful removal on a valuable page, paying someone competent is reasonable. Be sceptical of success rates you can't verify. A counter-notification is a sworn legal statement that can invite a lawsuit: read how counter-notices work and take qualified advice first.
Which one you need
- "Has anything been filed against my site?" Record check. Nothing else answers this.
- "Is this page in Google right now?" Index check, or an exact-phrase search in quotes: free and instant.
- "Who filed this and what did they claim?" Record check, then the notice link to Lumen.
- "My page vanished and I don't know why." Rule out technical causes, then run a record check. See the diagnostic table.
- "I need a counter-notice filed." A lawyer or a service, once you know what you're signing.
- "Tell me when something new appears." Monitoring, not a one-off check: the DMCA dashboard.
Questions worth asking of any tool
FAQs
What is the best DMCA checker?
It depends on the question. To find out whether requests have been filed against a domain you need a record check; an index scanner can't answer that. To see whether one page is in Google now, an exact-phrase search in quotes is free and immediate.
Can a DMCA checker tell me who filed the complaint?
Only a record check. Google's published data typically names the reporting organisation and the copyright owner; index-status scanners only measure whether a URL is present.
Is a free DMCA scan trustworthy?
Judge it on whether it names its data source and lets you verify a result. Be cautious where the free scan shows an alarming number but the detail sits behind a sales conversation.
Do I need a DMCA badge on my site?
No. Copyright exists on creation. A badge registers you with a vendor and carries no weight with Google. See dmca-site-verification.
Should I pay a service to file a counter-notice?
It can be reasonable for a valuable page and a genuinely wrongful removal, but a counter-notification is a sworn statement that can invite litigation. Read how counter-notices work and take qualified legal advice first.
Check your website now
Use the free DMCA checker: no sign-up, results in seconds.