Verify it in four checks
- Check the public recordA real complaint to Google Search normally appears in Google's published data, with a date, reporting organisation, copyright owner and URLs.
- Read the underlying noticeWhere a Lumen link exists, the archived notice shows what was sent, by whom and about what.
- Check your accounts directlySign in by typing the address yourself: a host or platform that acted will normally have recorded it there.
- Contact the sender independentlyUse the contact details on their own site. If they didn't send it, you have your answer, and they will generally want to know.
Two different things people call "fake"
They need opposite responses, and confusing them can turn an administrative problem into a legal one.
| A wrong notice | A fraudulent notice | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A real complaint from a real rights holder that names the wrong page or work, or misjudges a lawful use | Someone impersonating a rights holder, or inventing a claim, to extract money, credentials or clicks |
| How common | Very. Bulk automated enforcement produces errors constantly | Less common, but a persistent, well-established scam |
| Right response | Correct the record with the sender or the copyright owner | Don't engage. Verify independently, then report it |
| Avoid | Calling it fraud in writing | Paying, clicking, or opening the attachment |
An incorrect notice is not evidence of dishonesty. Genuine-but-wrong notices, including deliberate misuse by real parties, are covered in false and abusive takedowns.
Warning signs in the message
- It wants money. The strongest signal. A takedown notice asks a provider to remove material; it doesn't come with an invoice, settlement figure, crypto address or rising amount. Real settlements come from identifiable lawyers, on letterhead, citing a specific work and use, not a template demanding payment within 24 hours.
- The sender fails a lookup. Check the real email domain; display names are trivially forged. A real vendor or law firm has a site with history, a traceable registration, an address and a record of filings. A new domain mimicking a known firm is a common pattern.
- The work is vague. Genuine complaints name a specific photograph, article, track or film; scams say "copyrighted images on your website". A named work unrelated to your page is more often automation than fraud.
- An unexpected attachment holding the "evidence". Opening it is the point. Real notices put the URLs in the body.
- A link to "review the claim". Credential harvesting, dressed as a hosting panel, platform login or legal portal.
- Disproportionate urgency. Suspension or legal action "today" is pressure. Real processes take days and weeks.
- Small tells: garbled statutory language or non-existent provisions; a reply-to on another domain; your name or URL missing or merged from a list; an offer to "resolve" a delisting for a fee, which rights holders don't do.
Verifying a claim independently
Use the four checks above. Never verify with the phone number or email in the message: that's circular, and it's the part of the scam that most often works.
- Lumen: how to read a record.
- Google: a genuine copyright message also appears in Search Console. What the real notice looks like.
- A clean public record proves no matching Google Search request exists, not that the message is fake: notices sent to your host, a platform or you never appear there. It's still strong evidence, and so is a request that doesn't match the email's story.
If you conclude it is a scam
If it turns out to be genuine
Work out what was named, by whom, and whether it's correct: what a copyright infringement notice means and how the takedown process works. If you think material was removed by mistake, read what a counter-notice involves first: the response has consequences of its own.
FAQs
How do I know if a copyright infringement notice is real?
Verify facts the sender doesn't control: look for a matching request in Google's public copyright-removal records, check your platform and hosting accounts directly, and contact the named firm using details you found yourself. Run a check on the domain.
Do real DMCA notices ask for payment?
A takedown notice asks a service provider to remove material; it is not a bill. Genuine rights holders do pursue settlements, but through identifiable lawyers citing a specific work and use, not a template email demanding a transfer within 24 hours.
Is a wrong notice the same as a fake one?
No. Automated bulk enforcement produces incorrect notices constantly from genuine senders. Calling a mistaken notice fraudulent in writing can create a problem you didn't have, so handle errors as corrections.
The email says my site will be suspended today. Is that plausible?
Hosts do act on notices, but manufactured urgency is a standard pressure tactic. Check your hosting account directly, by typing the address rather than following any link.
If no request shows up in the public record, is the notice definitely fake?
No. Google's published data covers requests to Google Search; a notice sent to your host, a platform or you directly would never appear there. A clean check is useful evidence, not proof either way.
Should I reply to a suspected scam notice?
Replying confirms the address is monitored and usually invites more. Preserve the message with its headers, verify independently, and report it to your email provider and the organisation being impersonated.
Check your website now
Use the free DMCA checker: no sign-up, results in seconds.